Bears Come Out of Hibernation

Adam Turnquist | Chief Technical Strategist

Last Updated:

Like clockwork, the arrival of spring has awoken the bears from a deep winter slumber. The silencing 10% first-quarter S&P 500 rally was interrupted by alarm over escalating geopolitical conflicts in the Middle East, reduced rate cut expectations, and surging interest rates as confidence in the Federal Reserve’s (Fed) battle against inflation was shaken. Equity markets reacted by pulling back from overbought levels, while Treasury yields rerated significantly higher. Sentiment followed price, and bears woke up from hibernation this month.

Since 1987, the American Association of Individual Investors (AAII) has surveyed its members each week with a simple question: “Do you feel the direction of the stock market over the next six months will be up (bullish), no change (neutral) or down (bearish)?” The bullish, bearish, and neutral percentage readings provide a temperature gauge for risk appetite among investors. Investors also use the readings as contrarian indicators when bullish and bearish sentiment reaches extremes.

The chart below breaks down the weekly AAII bullish (top) and bearish (middle) percent readings, along with the spread between the data series shown in the bottom panel (Bull-Bear Index).

Sentiment Changes Directions

Line graph depicting AAII bullish and bearish percentages along with a Bull-Bear Index spread between the data series as depicted in the preceding paragraph. 

Source: LPL Research, American Association of Individual Investors, Bloomberg 04/25/24
Disclosures: Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All indexes are unmanaged and can’t be invested in directly.

Bullish sentiment had been trending above average all year. Optimistic expectations for interest rate cuts, stronger than expected economic data and earnings, and excitement over artificial intelligence have all supported investor enthusiasm. However, sentiment began to sour as the market adjusted to a higher for longer monetary policy backdrop. Most would argue it was overdue as areas of froth were emerging amid overbought market conditions.

Last week, bearish sentiment jumped nearly 10% to 34%, snapping 23 weeks of below-average bearish sentiment. And while bearish sentiment was mostly unchanged this week, bullish sentiment dropped 6% to only 32% this week, down from over 50% last month and breaking below its long-term average for the first time in 25 weeks.

Combining bullish and bearish sentiment provides a more comprehensive perspective of risk appetite. As shown in the bottom panel, the bull-bear spread dipped into negative territory for the first time since early November.

What Does This Mean for Stocks?

The transition to bears outpacing bulls after a lengthy period hints at a potential change in the character of this bull market. Based on comparable periods when prolonged bullish sentiment ended, history points to positive but relatively subpar equity market returns over the next 12 months. The table below highlights the longest periods with a positive bull-bear spread and the performance of the S&P 500 during and after the streak ends. On average, the index was up 4.1% 12 months after the bull-bear spread turned negative, with 69% of occurrences producing positive returns. This compares to the average 12-month S&P 500 return of 9.3% for all periods across the same time frame.

AAII Bull-Bear Spread Turns Negative for the First Time Since November

 

 

 

Performance After Bull-Bear Spread Turns Negative

End of Streak

Consecutive Weeks in Positive Territory

Performance During Period

+1-month

+3-months

+6-months

+12-months

5/29/1998

56

32.4%

4.4%

-5.8%

9.3%

19.3%

3/19/2004

50

27.6%

2.3%

2.3%

1.7%

7.2%

4/19/1996

33

10.0%

3.7%

-1.0%

10.2%

18.8%

3/24/2000

32

12.5%

-6.4%

-5.6%

-5.2%

-25.4%

3/13/2015

31

7.8%

1.9%

2.0%

-4.5%

-1.5%

5/28/1999

31

13.4%

2.3%

3.6%

8.8%

5.9%

6/23/1995

28

21.9%

0.7%

5.8%

11.3%

21.3%

3/11/2011

27

15.3%

1.5%

-2.6%

-11.5%

5.1%

4/19/2024

24

14.0%

-

-

-

-

7/16/2021

24

16.5%

3.5%

3.3%

7.8%

-10.7%

1/24/2014

22

9.2%

3.2%

4.9%

11.0%

14.6%

1/7/2005

20

6.9%

1.3%

0.4%

1.0%

8.4%

11/17/2000

20

-9.3%

-4.1%

-4.8%

-5.8%

-16.7%

4/24/1992

20

0.9%

1.2%

0.6%

1.2%

6.8%

 

 

Average

1.2%

0.2%

2.7%

4.1%

 

 

Median

1.9%

0.6%

1.7%

6.8%

 

 

Percent Positive

84.6%

61.5%

69.2%

69.2%

Source: LPL Research, American Association of Individual Investors, Bloomberg 04/25/24
Disclosures: Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All indexes are unmanaged and can’t be invested in directly.

Summary

While sentiment is clearly not a science and is often best utilized as a contrarian indicator, the end of prolonged below-average bearish sentiment and above-average bullish sentiment implies investors may be losing some confidence in the strength of this bull market. Technical evidence further supports this observation, as dip buyers stopped showing up near the S&P 500’s 20-day moving average earlier this month, providing a timely signal for a deeper pullback. LPL Research does not believe the recent shift in sentiment marks the end of the bull market and from a technical perspective, continues to consider the 4,800 area on the S&P 500 as a worst-case scenario for a drawdown. Confidence for a relatively limited drawdown is supported by breadth metrics holding up well, cyclical sector leadership, limited signs of panic in credit or volatility gauges, economic resiliency, and the longer-term momentum implications of this rally.

Adam Turnquist profile photo

Adam Turnquist

Adam Turnquist oversees the management and development of technical research at LPL Financial. His investment career spans over 15 years.